CategoriesCoin Article

A Collector’s Guide to Proof Coins

Proof coins offer an important option for numismatists.  Proofs are special versions of regular circulating coins that are manufactured for sale to collectors.  Precious metal bullion coins and commemorative coins are also frequently struck in proof format.  Modern proofs typically have deeply mirrored, highly reflective fields and frosty white devices (portraits, dates, images, and legends).  Many countries produce proof coinage;  some nations have been cranking them out since the 1800s, or even longer.  In the United States, proofs are struck from specially-made polished planchets and the dies are treated to generate the desired mirror fields and frosted features.  Proofs are generally struck using two cycles of the coin press, to ensure all design elements have maximum detail and surface quality.  The resulting coins represent “state of the art” in coin production.  In recent years the US Mint has offered variations on their traditional proof format, such as “reverse proofs” which have frosted fields and brilliantly shiny and reflective devices.

Although various “specimen” coins have been produced at the Philadelphia mint from its earliest years, the first no-question proof US coins were made around 1817.  The earliest example I could find on the Heritage website (www.ha.com) was an 1818 quarter, graded NGC Proof-67.  This amazing coin sold at auction in 2019 for $288,000.  The first copper and gold US proof coins also appeared around this time.  Proof mintages during these early years were extremely small and surviving examples are few and far between.

Coin collecting in the US became much more popular around 1857 when large cent and half cent production was discontinued.  The Philadelphia mint began producing annual sets of proof coins for sale to the general public starting in 1858.  Clients could purchase minor coin sets (cents, two and three cent pieces, and nickels), silver sets including half dimes through silver dollars, and complete sets with gold denominations.  Some proof coins could also be ordered individually.  Mintage numbers were in the hundreds for most silver proofs and up to a few thousand for minor coins.  For most gold proof issues only a couple dozen pieces were generally made.  Classic gold proof coins from the 1800s and early 1900s have been called the caviar of numismatics, to reflect their great rarity and value.

Proof examples of each denomination (including gold coins) continued to be minted through 1915.  Production was discontinued until 1936 when new 5-coin sets were produced.  Proof coinage again took a break after 1942, resuming in 1950.  One final break happened from 1965-1967;  from 1968 on proof sets have been made every year.

Modern proof sets are plentiful.  Most sets containing clad coins had mintage numbers in the millions and are often available to collectors at a cost lower than the original issue price.  Modern silver proof sets have been made since 1992 and include dimes, quarters, and half dollars struck in 90% silver.  These sets are priced according to their silver content;  their cost went way up in early 2026 due to the huge increase in the spot price of silver.  Modern proof coins are beautiful and so perfectly made that many qualify for the ultimate Proof-70 grade at major grading services.  If you want super quality coins at a small price these sets will do the trick.  They are especially nice as gifts for novice collectors.  FNS typically purchases several dozen modern sets to be used as prizes in our Coin Safari activity for Young Numismatists, at our annual coin show. 

Classic proof coins issued before 1916 can be surprisingly available.  These proof coins were (obviously) made for collectors who typically took good care of them.  Many of the coins produced and sold have survived in high grade.  The (relatively) large population of available pieces means prices can be somewhat affordable, in some cases significantly lower than the cost of comparable mint state (business strike) pieces from the same years.  If you are looking for beautiful examples of classic type coins it can make sense to go for proof coins.

As of June, 2026 it is possible to buy some classic proof coins at what might be considered affordable prices.  A quick look at fixed-price listings from a major online dealer spots some potential bargains.  How about a beautifully toned 1899 Indian Cent graded Proof-65 red-brown, for $750?  An 1882 Three-cent Nickel in PCGS PR-66 will set you back $715.  An 1881 Shield nickel in NGC PR-66 is currently priced at $850.   An 1883 Seated Liberty silver dime in PCGS PR-63 can be yours for just $675.  These prices aren’t exactly cheap, but considering these are extremely high-quality collector coins well over 100 years old, they will appeal to many collectors.

Here is an example of classic proof coinage.  This is a three-cent nickel coin from 1884.  The devices all show white mint frost while the fields have clear mirrored surfaces.  The contrast between the dark-appearing fields and the white devices produces an effect called Cameo.  In general, the greater the contrast between fields and devices, the greater the eye appeal and potential value for a buyer.  This particular coin is graded PR-65 by PCGS.

In many cases a classic proof will give you a thrilling combination of beauty, quality, and that special “cool factor” that makes the piece irresistible.  Sometimes they can even save you money compared to a business strike example of the same date and type.  These are terrific coins that would grace any collection and are within reach of many collectors.  If you prefer high quality at a much lower price, modern proofs will fit into any collecting budget.  So, next time you are in the mood for some truly beautiful coins, take a look at the proofs!

CategoriesCoin Article

A Brief Discussion About Replica Coins

Replica coins are privately-made copies of genuine coins.  They are usually made not to be spent as counterfeit money, but rather to substitute for collectible coins in a collection.  They are commonly encountered by coin collectors and it is important for collectors to be able to recognize them and distinguish them from genuine coins.  The grading service industry was established in part to provide expert authentication to certify that a valuable coin is in fact a legitimate example.

There is nothing inherently evil about a replica coin.  There is a place for replicas in numismatics, particularly in cases where a genuine piece is rare and expensive.  A well-made replica can be a pleasing acquisition and may satisfy the collector who wants to “fill that hole” in their collection, without taking out a second mortgage.  The danger is when the seller represents the replica as a genuine coin and attempts to defraud the buyer.

The biggest source of deceptive replicas is probably China.  There are no real legal barriers in China to prevent manufacture of what are straight-up counterfeit coins.  Almost every type of collectible US coin has been “made in China” and many of these enter the collecting market.  Some of these fakes are quite crude while others are extremely deceptive, matching the original designs quite closely and even being composed of the same metal alloys as original pieces.  Some issues like US Trade dollars, Seated Liberty dollars, and three-dollar gold pieces are notorious for being counterfeited.  Such “coins” have often appeared in online sales venues like eBay and others.  Some sellers are ignorant of the counterfeit nature of the lots, while others are fully aware and are actively trying to defraud a buyer.  You sometimes see listings of an obvious counterfeit, with a description like “found in Grandpa’s safe” or “handed down by a relative.”  Such comments are usually weak attempts to hide a fraudulent origin.  EBay to its credit does try to exclude counterfeit coin listings and will delete them if detected.

There are legitimate replica coins that are made and sold ethically.  The Hobby Protection Act of 1973 made provisions for the legal production and sale of imitation or replica numismatic items.  Specifically, replica coins can be made but they must be prominently engraved with the word “COPY.”  A company named The Gallery Mint made high-quality replicas of such rarities as the 1796 Quarter, the 1793 Wreath Cent, and the 1796 Quarter Eagle.  These pieces were made using (respectively) the silver, copper, and gold alloys used for the original coins and an authentic screw press was employed to do the actual striking.  The “Copy” stamp was applied to obverse or reverse, as preferred by the customer.  The Gallery Mint is no longer in business but their products still appear on the market.

A currently-operating company called The Moonlight Mint is the brainchild of engraver and sculptor Daniel Carr.  Moonlight Mint has made “fantasy” coins including near-perfect replicas of genuine US designs.  Moonlight Mint avoids the restrictions of the Hobby Protection Act by making pieces with dates that were never used for actual circulating coins.  Since these products do not replicate “real” coins they do not need to carry the COPY engraving.  One example is the 1964-D Peace Dollar, which was actually made at the Denver Mint in 1964 but was never issued and all examples were destroyed.  Daniel Carr recreated these pieces and struck them on actual US silver dollars so the weight and silver content would be exactly correct.  The limited-edition run of this piece rapidly sold out and examples currently are resold legally and at a very steep price.

Another Moonlight Mint product is a Peace dollar dated 1931-S.  Since no genuine Peace dollars were minted in 1931 it was not illegal to produce and sell this fantasy issue.  Genuine US silver dollars were used as the planchets and these 1931-S pieces were struck in high relief like the original 1921 Peace dollar.  Even though this is not a genuine US Mint product, it is a beautiful piece that might appeal to any collector, especially one who appreciates Peace dollars.  Here are images of this fantasy coin.

In summary, replica coins are legitimate collectibles, as long as the distinction between replica and authentic pieces is clear.  Collectors must be aware that authenticity for collectible coins is always a concern.  Any potential purchase should be examined closely until the buyer is satisfied it is a genuine piece.  You can help ensure you are getting a genuine coin if you buy a certified example, especially if the coin is particularly valuable or is a type that is commonly counterfeited.  Enjoy your collection, but, as always, buyer beware!  

CategoriesCoin Article

History and Coinage Operations of the New Orleans Mint

The New Orleans Mint in Louisiana operated from 1838 through 1861, and again from 1879 through 1909.  Coins minted in New Orleans bear the distinctive “O” mintmark and are an important focus for numismatists.  The history of the mint and details about its operations are fascinating subjects for study.  This article explores this topic and offers some specific information about the manufacturing processes employed during the mint’s years of coin production.

President Andrew Jackson was a military hero based on his decisive victory over British forces at the Battle of New Orleans, at the tail end of the War of 1812.  During his presidency he was a proponent of creating branch mints to increase the production of United States coinage.  On March 3, 1835 Jackson signed a bill authorizing the construction of three new mints, to be located at Dahlonega, Georgia, Charlotte, North Carolina, and New Orleans, Louisiana.  The Dahlonega and Charlotte mints were relatively small facilities and produced gold coins only.  Both of those mints closed at the onset of the Civil War and never reopened.  The much larger New Orleans mint produced gold and silver coins, in all denominations.  Although this facility also closed during the Civil War it reopened in 1879 and continued to manufacture gold and silver coins until 1909.

 Historical records include many contemporary references that describe in detail the production processes employed at the New Orleans Mint.  From the acquisition of the gold and silver raw material to the eventual shipment of the finished coins, the entire minting operation is a fascinating area of study.  The New Orleans mint operated in an era when coal-fired steam engines powered the equipment, horse-drawn wagons were a primary means of transportation, and electricity and the internal combustion engine were just coming into widespread use.  The Mint nevertheless developed machines and procedures that allowed the efficient production of coins on a tremendous scale.

The New Orleans mint typically received precious metal in the form of dust, ingots, foreign coins, and old jewelry.  The depositor was given a receipt and charged a fee if refining was needed to prepare the metal for coinage.  The metal was assayed and the result reported to the mint treasurer.  Once the value of the metal was determined the depositor presented his receipt and was paid in US currency.

The refined, alloyed metal was melted and cast into standard-sized ingots which were repeatedly passed through a rolling mill to create metal strip of the proper thickness.  The strips were heated and cooled (a process called annealing) as needed to keep the metal malleable.  The final thickness adjustment was made at a “drawing bench” where the strips were drawn between precisely calibrated steel cylinders.  A vertical steel punch apparatus was then used to cut out the circular coin planchets.  Each punch at maximum operating speed could turn out 225 planchets per minute.  The strip scrap remaining after planchets were punched out was returned to the furnace for re-melting.  In fact, all gold and silver scrap was carefully monitored and controlled, with very little loss.

Female employees were generally hired to sort the planchets to ensure the weights were correct.  Light planchets were returned for re-melting while heavy ones were hand-filed to correct the weights.  Approved planchets proceeded to the milling room, where they were compressed between a rotating steel wheel and a stationary wall;  this created a uniform raised rim on each planchet.  Depending on denomination, between 500 and 1200 planchets could be milled per minute.  Finished planchets were annealed, washed, and sent to the coining room.

Different coining presses were employed for different coin denominations.  Planchets were fed into brass tubes from which they were removed and placed in the coining chamber by steel feeder fingers.  The dies closed on the planchet with a force of around 150 tons of pressure to create each coin.  The feeders simultaneously grasped the finished coin and the next planchet;  the feeder motion then transferred the coin into a collection hamper and placed the planchet into the coining chamber.  The rate of coin production was generally about 85 coins per minute, per press.

Finished coins were inspected, weighed, and packaged in boxes.  The filled boxes were weighed in the presence of the treasurer.  If the weight was correct, the sealed box was placed in a vault.  Samples corresponding to each potential shipment were sent to the assay department at the Philadelphia mint for review.  If approved, each shipment was made available for coinage orders.  If samples were rejected, the affected production run was condemned and re-melted.

During its years of operation (from 1838 to 1861 and from 1879 to 1909) the New Orleans mint produced silver 3-cent pieces, half dimes, dimes, quarters, half dollars, and dollars.  With the exception of the 4-dollar Stella patterns, New Orleans produced gold coins in all denominations:  gold dollars, quarter eagles, three-dollar gold pieces, half eagles, eagles, and double eagles.  The gold and silver coins from New Orleans include many rare and valuable issues.  Among these are the extremely rare 1838-O proof half dollars, the 1856-O gold double eagle, and the unique proof 1844-O eagle and half eagle coins.  However, many more issues are common and easily within reach for the average collector.  The coinage of New Orleans is an important and popular focus for numismatists.  Every collector of United States coins should own at least one example struck at the legendary New Orleans mint. 

CategoriesCoin Article

The True (?) Story of the 1792 Half Disme

Prominent coin dealer and former ANA President Jeff Garrett wrote an interesting article about the 1792 Half Disme which was posted on the NGC website on 06/18/2020.  The article discussed the history of this special coin and reported on some new research that casts new light on its probable origin story.  This research has uncovered clear evidence that these coins were struck for general circulation and, unlike other denomination coins struck in 1792, were not patterns.  Accordingly, the newest edition of the Red Book (as of 2020) lists this coin in the regular-issue Half Dime section.  Incidentally, the word disme is an obsolete French word meaning “a tenth part”.  It is pronounced “deem”.

It is generally agreed that an attempt to develop a national coinage was made in 1792.  1,500 silver half dismes were coined by U.S. Mint employees in the basement of saw maker John Harper’s Philadelphia factory.  There are two commonly-reported legends associated with this important event.  The first is that George Washington provided his own silverware to be melted down for the production of the coins.  The second is that Martha Washington was the model for the portrait used on the coins.   Recent research as related by Mr. Garrett tells a somewhat different story.

Thomas Jefferson maintained a personal ledger of income and expenses which he called his Memorandum Book.  An entry dated July 11, 1792 reads “Delivd. 75.D at the mint to be coined” and on July 13 another entry reads “Rec’d from the mint 1500. half dismes of the new coinage”.  75 Spanish milled dollars (75.D) contain the exact amount of silver needed to make 1500 half dismes.  That same day (July 13, 1792) Jefferson left Philadelphia to begin his summer vacation at Monticello.  His Memorandum Book records that he made numerous expenditures of 5 cents or multiples of that amount on his trip.  This information constitutes strong evidence that not only was Thomas Jefferson directly involved in the production of the 1792 half dismes, he also regarded them as circulating coinage and personally used them as such.  

Another indicator of the regular-coinage status of the half disme is found in President Washington’s fourth annual message to Congress on November 6, 1792, in which Washington specifically stated that the half dismes had been made as regular coinage.  One additional relevant piece of information is that a unique example of the half disme is known that was struck in pure copper.  The existence of this piece suggests the dies were first tested using a base metal planchet, after which the production run was completed using Jefferson’s silver.  The copper example then would be the actual pattern half disme coin.

Many examples of  1792 half dismes are known in various circulated grades.  Some pieces are holed and presumably were worn as jewelry.  A few gems are known and these are among the most desirable coins in all of numismatics.   The current price record (as of 2020) is held by the finest known example, graded NGC MS-68.  This spectacular toned beauty is pedigreed to David Rittenhouse, the first director of the US Mint.  It was sold in 2018 by Classic Coin Company for $1,985,000.  That’s only 39.7 million times face value!  Here are images of this amazing coin.

Now that the true history of the half disme is known, demand for these iconic American treasures might become even more intense.  It seems likely that new record prices may be set in the future.

CategoriesCoin Article

Silver Content Analysis for Selected Ancient Coins

The first silver coins were produced around 600 BC in various locations including Lydia (in present-day Turkey) and India. The Greeks began striking silver coins before 500 BC and were likely the most prolific silver coin producers of their time. Silver coin production continued with the Romans and with practically every other empire, kingdom, and country for the following two thousand years. It’s only in the modern age that circulating silver coinage has been discontinued. While silver is obviously still a precious metal, it is no longer used to make coins for commerce.

Ancient artisans learned how to purify silver long before the first coins were struck. Even the earliest silver coins were generally composed of high-grade silver, with fineness of 95% or greater. This situation continued into Roman Republic times but things changed during the time of Imperial Rome. It’s well known that during the later years of the Roman empire the silver content of their coinage was steadily reduced.  Eventually some Roman coins like the Antoninianus were basically just copper with a thin coating of silver.  Many crude contemporary forgeries were made and by the late 3rd century AD these debased coins were practically worthless.  They were often just discarded.

I have six ancient silver coins in my collection and I thought it would be interesting to measure their actual silver content.  Through the kind assistance of employees of a local coin shop (Fresno Coin Gallery, in Fresno, CA) I was able to get elemental analyses of these coins.  Fresno Coin has an XRF analyzer which they mostly use to evaluate jewelry for precious metal content.  This instrument generated the results for these coins.

The first sample we examined was my Athens Attica tetradrachm, minted between 449 and 413 BC.  Here are some photos of this coin:


Silver content tested at 98.7%, with lead present at a level of 1.3%.  The ancient Greeks used a cupellation tecnique to purify silver, in which lead contaminant was adsorbed into the clay lining of the melting furnace.  Obviously when they prepared the silver that went into my tetradrachm there was still some lead impurity remaining.

The second coin is a Kings of Macedon Alexander tetradrachm minted approximately 325 BC.  Here are images:

This piece showed 99.7% silver, with 0.3% gold as the only detected contaminant.  It appears that by 325 BC the Greeks were quite adept at purifying silver for coinage

The next example is a Roman Republic serrate denarius minted in 79 BC:

Silver content was 98.7%, with copper, gold, and lead traces present (at levels of 0.6%, 0.4%, and 0.2%, respectively).  In general the denarii minted during the Roman Republic era were expected to be high-quality silver.  This piece provides evidence that this is true.  This coin weighs 4.00 grams, so the actual pure silver content is about 3.95 grams.

Next up is the Egypt, Alexandria tetradrachm that was described in last month’s newsletter.  Here are images of this interesting coin:

Minted around 136-137 AD during the reign of the Emperor Hadrian, this billon-alloy coin weighs 12.85 grams and tested at 28.1% silver.  The main component was copper (71.8%).  There was just a trace of lead present.

One on-line coin reference I found asserted that these provincial tetradrachm coins were designed to contain the same amount of silver as the smaller denarius coin which was more well-known in the Roman Empire.  At 28.1% silver content, my Hadrian tetradrachm has about 3.61 grams of silver, which in fact is fairly close to the silver content of the earlier serrate denarius described above.

 The next example is a denarius minted in 200 AD, featuring the portrait of Julia Domna, wife of the emperor Septimus Severus:

Silver content reduction in denarii in the Roman Empire was well underway by this time.  The XRF results confirm this fact, with silver content measured at 75.1%.  Copper content was 23.8%, lead measured at 0.6%, and gold was present at 0.4%.

The last subject is another denarius, this one minted in 220 AD and featuring Julia Paula, wife of Emperor Elagabalus.

This coin demonstrates the further debasement of Roman coinage.  Silver tested at 64.4%.  Copper was 31.0%, lead was at 0.7%, and gold content was 0.45%.  This coin was the only one in this group to show tin which was present at 3.4%.  Tin is a normal component of bronze coinage.  Perhaps worn-out bronze coins were added to the melting pot as part of the process to reduce overall silver content in the finished coins.

This was obviously a very small sampling of ancient coins, but one fact seems apparent. Ancient silver processing technology was fully capable of producing coinage silver of consistently high purity. The production of low-silver coinage during the later years of the Roman Empire was a deliberate policy choice. This choice allowed the manufacture of more coins from a given quantity of pure silver, but the inevitable result was a gradual loss of public confidence in the currency. There are many reasons why the Roman Empire eventually fell, but the debasement of their coins probably didn’t help. 

CategoriesCoin Article

Error Coins

Often errors occur during the coin manufacturing process. Depending on the nature of the error, the resulting abnormal coin may have no significant extra value, it may carry a slight to moderate value premium to an error specialist, or it may be very valuable. This article shows examples of several types of error coins.

This is a Flying Eagle cent with a “clipped planchet” error. The blank disc (“planchet”) which was struck to produce this coin was missing a small section, probably because the punch that cut out the planchet slightly overlapped the hole from a previously-punched planchet. This produces an error known as a “curved clip”, where the finished coin is missing a small portion of its circumference. As of 2024 a normal Flying Eagle cent in this grade might sell for about $70. Flying Eagle cents are seldom seen with errors. This example with the minor clipped planchet might fetch an extra $50 or so from an interested error collector.

Another type of error occurs when a piece of debris finds its way into the coining chamber. The debris is stamped onto the surface of the coin when the strike is performed. This error type is commonly known as a “strike-thru”. The debris may or may not end up attached to the finished coin. This Kennedy half dollar had a small piece of iron or steel stamped into its surface. The inclusion became firmly bonded to the coin surface and is therefore referred to as “retained.” A 1967 Kennedy half dollar is a very common coin, worth only a few dollars. The error could easily inflate the value to $50 or more.

Sometimes a coin fails to properly eject from the coin press after it is struck. If it falls back over the coining chamber it may be struck a second time. The second strike usually obliterates the portion of the design that is between the dies and creates a new struck image. The new image may be off-center by a random degree. The resulting error coin can be quite spectacular. This 1999-D Jefferson nickel was double struck in such a manner that the final coin has two dates. It has been graded an encapsulated as a double-struck error coin by the ANACS coin grading service.

Sometimes the die itself can be manufactured with a defect. A “doubled die” error is fairly common for various US coins. The actual dies that are used to strike coins are generally made by pressing a master die onto the steel working die to transfer the engraved coin design. This process generally requires repeated pressings to completely transfer the design. The working die is heated and cooled (annealed) between pressings to soften the steel. If the working die is misaligned with the master die during the final pressing the finished die may show doubling of some or all of the design elements.

The most famous example of this error type is the 1955 Doubled Die Lincoln cent, which has dramatic separation of the doubled design elements on the obverse. These cents are very popular among error collectors and command high prices. Less spectacular doubled die coin however are rather common and generally don’t cost very much. The 1964-D Kennedy Half Dollar can be found with several different doubled die errors. Minor doubling is most obvious on the letters of In God We Trust on the obverse. There are even tripled and quadrupled die versions known. The doubling effect is fairly small for these coins and you need magnification to see the doubling clearly. Here is an example that was found among a group of ordinary 1964 half dollars.

Yet another error class is known as a Rotated Die error. The obverse and reverse dies for United States coins are positioned such that a struck coin has “coin alignment” for the front and back designs. If you hold a normal coin with obverse image in the vertical position and then flip the coin around its horizontal axis, the reverse image will appear “right side up”. Sometimes however, the dies may be installed incorrectly in the press, or get twisted due to equipment wear or damage. Any coins struck at that point will have incorrect alignment of the obverse and reverse designs.

Rotated die errors were common during the early years of United States coinage. However, with improving technology and greater precision for machine manufacturing, modern coins rarely show any die rotation errors. This 1983-S Kennedy Half Dollar is one of those rare exceptions. Somehow the reverse die became rotated by about 90 degrees (a one-quarter turn) and this spectacular error was generated. It is even more exotic because the coin is a proof striking, made specifically for coin collectors. Proof coins are supposedly inspected for quality before they are packaged for sale. Somehow this coin made it past the inspectors. Apparently, it was eventually broken out of its original government packaging and spent since it was discovered in a roll of mixed half dollars obtained at face value from a bank. It’s a very rare coin, purchased for face value!

Yet another type of error became possible when the United Stated Mint began striking clad coinage in 1965. Dimes, quarters, and half dollars were made from a “sandwich” of three metal layers. The top and bottom layers were composed of a copper-nickel alloy while the center layer was pure copper. The alloy layers have a silvery-white color, while the copper interior has a coppery brown-orange color. You can see the copper layer on most modern coins by looking at the edge of the coin. Such coins are commonly referred to as clad coins.

On rare occasions a blank planchet prepared for a clad coin is missing some or all of one of the clad layers. In this case some or all of the copper interior layer will be exposed, usually on just one side. This 1979-D Washington Quarter is an excellent example of this type of error. The alloy outer layer was completely missing on one side so the struck coin ended up with a normal-looking reverse and a copper-colored obverse. Since a clad layer represents a significant amount of the mass of a normal coin, this error piece is around 20% lighter in weight than a normal quarter. By the way, this coin was found in change from a vending machine; another fantastic error coin obtained at face value!

CategoriesCoin Article

The Silver “Owl” of Ancient Greece

The Fresno Numismatic Society hosted our annual Coin Show on October 23 and 24, 2020.  As usual, we had an excellent group of dealers who offered a great variety of coins and currency.  I spotted an exceptional coin in the display case of dealer Glen Schinke.  It is an Athens Attica silver tetradrachm from ancient Greece.  This coin is popularly known as an “owl” because of the owl figure that dominates the reverse side.  I have been aware of this coin ever since my parents picked up a brass replica piece at the New York Natural History Museum in about 1964.  It only took 56 years, but I finally have one to call my own.  Even though it’s over 2400 years old, it is extremely well-made and well-preserved.  Here are some photos of this wonderful coin.

Obverse

Reverse

The Owl is perhaps the most iconic and famous of all ancient coins.  It represented about one week’s pay for a soldier in ancient Greece and was minted in huge numbers in various forms, for several hundred years.  It is regarded as the first successful international coin, widely recognized and accepted throughout the ancient world.  The silver tetradrachm is widely believed to the type of coin given to Judas for the betrayal of Jesus.  Legend has it that President Theodore Roosevelt carried an Owl coin and that it was in part the inspiration for Roosevelt’s interest in redesigning American coinage.

The Owl is pictured on the 1-euro coin of modern Greece and remains a symbol of the Greek city of Athens.  The images on both sides of the coin refer to the goddess Athena.  The obverse features the head of the goddess.  She wears an ornate earring and Attic helmet adorned with olive leaves.  The reverse shows the Athenian owl which represents Athena.  The actual owl species depicted on the coins is believed to be the “little owl” (scientific name Athene noctua) which is native to the Mediterranean region.

The reverse legend reads AƟE (alpha-theta-epsilon).  This is an abbreviation which translates to “of the Athenians”.  There is a small crescent moon and an olive sprig with one berry.  According to mythology, Athena brought the olive tree to Athens as a gift, in order to impress Zeus and outshine rival god Poseidon.

There are three general styles of Owls corresponding to different production dates.  The so-called Archaic type was first minted around 515 BC.  These are very scarce and expensive and despite their crude manufacturing quality are avidly sought by collectors.  The “Classical” Owls were produced in large quantities starting around 465 BC and continuing until the defeat of Athens by Sparta in 404 BC.  My coin is a classical-style piece with production date estimated between 449-413 BC by Glen Schinke.  Coins minted after 404 BC are called “Late Classical”, were struck on a smaller planchet, and are less popular with collectors.

Beginning around 165 BC “New Style” coins were issued.  These coins were struck on wider, thinner planchets and feature major changes to the reverse especially.  The owl image remains, but it now perches on an amphora and the fields include a grape bunch, an encircling laurel wreath, and text indicating the issuing magistrate.  The magistrate information allows more precise dating of these pieces.  Dating for the Archaic and Classical pieces is less certain.  Even major auction houses can disagree on dating for these earlier issues.

Owl silver is typically >99% pure.  Traces of copper and gold are present, in concentrations of less than 0.25% and 0.04%, respectively.  The silver ore was extracted from the Laurion mine complex located near Athens and was refined by smelting and cupellation processes which at the time were likely the most sophisticated in the world.  During many decades of operation, the estimated total production of silver from Laurion exceeded 3,000 tons.

It is believed that Owl planchets were prepared by pouring molten silver into molds that were sized to contain the proper amount of metal.  Target weight for a finished Owl was about 17.2 grams and most intact Owls in fact weigh between 17.0 and 17.2 grams.  The dies were likely made of bronze and were hand-engraved using burins, drills, chisels, and punches.  The obverse die was set into an anvil and the planchet placed on the die.  The reverse die was then positioned on the planchet and hand-struck with a heavy hammer. The reverse dies tended to wear out faster than the obverses.

Many Owls have test-cuts which were inflicted in ancient times to verify the coins were solid silver, not some plated base metal.  Others show countermarks punched in by merchants to confirm the coins were acceptable for commerce. No matter how you slice it, Owls are remarkable, historic, and beautiful coins.  I’m happy to finally have one in my collection.

CategoriesCoin Article

Why Attend a Coin Show?

Why Attend a Coin Show? In Particular, the Fresno Coin Show presented by the Fresno Numismatic Society?

So, why would anybody want to go to a coin show in the first place? It might seem obvious to a dedicated collector, but maybe we can define a few specific reasons. Just for the record: coin shows are awesome!

A coin show provides the opportunity to speak with many numismatic professionals, each with their own wealth of knowledge and experience. If you have questions about Lincoln cents, you can find dealers with decades of experience in that field. They can explain everything from the history of the design to the nuances of grading and the reasons for price differences between different dates. Suppose you are interested in ancient Rome. The Fresno Coin Show usually features dealers who are intimately familiar with the gold, silver, and copper coinage of Rome, including the historical significance of the designs. Even the decline and fall of the Roman Empire is reflected in the gradual debasement of their silver coins, which were made with less and less silver as economic conditions deteriorated. All our dealers are eager to share their historical and numismatic insights with show attendees.

The fact that many dealers are available at a show gives the potential buyer an opportunity to shop around for the best deals. Popular collector coins like Morgan silver dollars are included in most dealer inventories. Attendees can move from table to table, looking for the most attractive specimens and compare prices. Nothing inspires buyer confidence like having choices and a coin show provides that opportunity. When I go to a show, I take notes on each coin that interests me. I’ll then go back to review my candidates. When the coin, the price, and my interest level all line up I open my wallet. A coin show is the only place where all this can happen.

It is possible to haggle with coin dealers. Many coins in dealer cases show a price tag. In most cases, the dealers have some flexibility on pricing. If you see a coin you like, it’s perfectly OK to ask if the dealer will take an offer below the listed price. Suppose you see a coin priced at $100. You like the coin but the price seems a little steep. Perhaps you could offer $80 for the coin. The dealer might say “no”, he might say “yes”, or you might come to an agreement at a $90 price point. It doesn’t hurt to ask and as long as you are polite no dealer should be offended by an offer to negotiate. In my experience it’s pretty common to complete a purchase at a price around 10% below the amount shown on the tag.

The USA is obviously experiencing near-record inflation right now (October, 2023). It can be a smart move to put some of your cash in precious metals which may maintain value when dollars are losing buying power. TV and radio are full of advertisements by companies selling gold and silver, but the best place to procure precious metals is at a coin show. You can see and hold the item you want and can negotiate the best price.

One important consideration for purchasers is that counterfeit precious metal products exist. These are sometimes offered for sale on venues like Craigslist and eBay and buyers need to be cautious. Reputable dealers (like the ones who attend the Fresno Coin Show!) guarantee the authenticity of what they sell. If you want the ultimate guarantee of authenticity you can purchase professionally-certified gold and silver coins.

I’ll provide an example of how a reputable precious metal dealer should operate. A few years ago, the official price of gold (“spot price”) was $1800/troy ounce. One dealer was selling American gold Eagle coins which have a pure gold content of exactly 1 ounce. The price offered to me for one Eagle was $1880, which was an $80 premium over spot price. The dealer said if I want to sell him that coin and the spot price is still $1800, he would pay me $1810 for it. So, the dealer is operating on a profit margin of $70 on an $1800 purchase. This is an honest dealer who offers precious metal at a fair price.

If you have coins or currency to sell, you should make attending the Fresno show a priority. With many dealers in one place you can show your items around and find out what they are potentially worth. You can then close a deal with whoever makes the best offer. Appraisals at a show are free and you are under no obligation to sell. You might even find attractive coins, currency, or precious metal products and trade in your old items for new ones that better fit you collecting preferences. Come to the show and see what happens!

Finally, a coin show is just plain fun. It’s exciting to see all the valuable and beautiful products in dealer cases. Meeting fellow collectors and talking with the dealers is inspirational and educational. Highly recommended!

CategoriesCoin Article

The Mints that Coined Southern Gold

Charlotte, Dahlonega, and New Orleans

The first mint in the United States was established in Philadelphia and commenced regular coining operations in 1793. Despite the best efforts of mint personnel, for many years the output of the mint was not sufficient to meet the commerce requirements of the young nation. Official US coins circulated alongside a wide variety of foreign coins, private tokens, and paper bank notes. Gold coins in particular were practically unknown in circulation, primarily because the official standard ratio of 1 ounce of gold to 15 ounces of silver undervalued the gold in comparison to the European standard. Most American gold coins were exported and melted for bullion. This problem was eventually solved by the passage of a law in 1834 that reduced the amount of gold in the coins. It was no longer profitable to melt coins for bullion so they began to be seen in circulation.

The discovery of gold deposits in Georgia and North Carolina in 1828 precipitated the first American gold rush. Miners and settlers moved into these areas and the population grew rapidly. Several private coinage operations were started in order to convert the raw gold into usable coins. Chief among these were Templeton Reid and the Bechtlers. However, there was increasing demand to provide a means to make universally-accepted Federal coinage from the local raw metal. The recommended locations for new mint facilities were Charlotte, North Carolina and Dahlonega, Georgia. During this same period, Mint Director Samuel Moore was promoting the establishment of another new mint for the city of New Orleans, Louisiana. New Orleans was the transit point for commerce for the Mississippi Valley and much silver and gold from Mexico passed through the city. The proposals for three regional mints seemed reasonable to President Andrew Jackson and on March 3, 1835 he signed a bill authorizing the U.S. Treasury to establish branch mints at all three locations.

The Charlotte Mint

 Construction of the Charlotte mint facility started in December, 1835. The building was a T-shaped structure with the front section measuring 125 feet wide and 33.5 feet deep. The “upright” section of the T shape extended from the back of the main building, measuring 36 feet in width and 53 feet in length. The facility had two stories and a basement and was built from dressed stone. In the 1830’s Charlotte was already an established town with a reliable supply of materials and labor. Construction was carried out under the competent supervision of Major Samuel McComb and the project was completed without serious difficulty. The Philadelphia Mint dispatched Franklin Peale to inspect the Charlotte facility and he declared the new mint ready for operation by the end of 1837. Mr. John Wheeler became the first Superintendent.

The Charlotte mint operated for a total of 24 years, from 1838 to 1861 and was shut down after the onset of the Civil War. Only gold coins were struck at Charlotte, in denominations of one dollar, $2.50 (quarter eagles), and $5.00 (half eagles). The first coins were produced between March 26 and March 31, 1838, when 678 half eagles were struck. The Charlotte Journal reported the event, stating “We have the pleasure of announcing this week, that our Mint has commenced coining – there is no mistake now, for we have both seen and handled the yellow boys.” Mint operations were interrupted in 1844 when a fire broke out in the wing where the coin presses were located. The facility was severely damaged and its contents were almost completely destroyed. Due to the production shutdown relatively few 1844-dated Charlotte quarter eagles and half eagles were made and they are somewhat scarce. No coins were produced in 1845 but the mint was restored to operation by 1846 and coinage resumed. Production continued until the final shutdown in 1861.

The Charlotte mint building was put into service as a U.S. Assay Office in 1868 and there was an unsuccessful attempt to re-open the facility as a U.S. Branch Mint in 1873. The assay office closed in 1913 and the building subsequently saw service as a Federal courthouse, headquarters for the Red Cross (during WWI) and as a meeting place for the Charlotte Women’s Club. In 1932 the structure was dismantled and later reconstructed in a new Charlotte location, opening in 1936 as the Mint Museum of Art. This museum remains open today.

One-year Charlotte type coins:

  • 1849 Open Wreath gold dollar
  • 1855 Type 2 gold dollar
  • 1838 Classic Head half eagle
  • 1839 Liberty Head half eagle, with obverse mint mark.

1855-C Half Eagle, graded PCGS XF-45.

The Dahlonega Mint 

The design for the Dahlonega mint building was the same as that for the Charlotte facility. However, the town of Dahlonega (which is a word from the Cherokee language, meaning “yellow money”) did not exist prior to the 1828 gold strikes. The area was basically a wilderness and construction of the mint was plagued by shortages of building materials and skilled labor. The Commissioner of Construction was Ignatius Few, a lawyer and Methodist minister who apparently did a very poor job of overseeing the construction process. When Franklin Peale inspected the site in 1837 he found the quality of work to be abysmal. He reported back to the Philadelphia Mint that the Dahlonega workmen “certainly deserve diplomas for Botching”. Nevertheless, the facility was eventually approved and the first 80 half eagles were struck on April 21, 1838. The Dahlonega mint superintendent Joseph Singleton remarked that the coins were beautiful, accurate, and had “a most cordial reception wherever carried.” During its years of operation Dahlonega produced gold coins only, in denominations of one dollar, $2.50 (quarter eagles), $3.00, and $5.00 (half eagles).

The Dahlonega mint accepted gold dust, nuggets, bullion, and foreign coins for conversion into Federal coins. Depositors would first present their gold at the counter of the Superintendent/Treasurer and would be issued a receipt. The gold was melted and assayed to establish its fineness and corresponding value. Most Georgia gold was more pure than the 90% standard for Federal coins and the practice was to leave the naturally-occurring silver in the alloy and add copper until the target purity was reached. The alloy would then be coined and depositors would return to pick up their brand-new Dahlonega gold pieces.

After the discovery of gold in California a significant amount of California gold was transported to Dahlonega for coining. One estimate is that about 20% of the total output from the mint was produced from California gold. With the opening of the San Francisco mint in 1855 shipments of California gold to Dahlonega largely stopped.

The state of Georgia seceded from the Union in January, 1861. Dahlonega struck 1597 half eagles in February while the mint was still operating under the authority of the United States government. After mint superintendent George Kellogg tendered his resignation to President Lincoln in April, the mint struck approximately 1600 more half eagles and about 3000 gold dollars. All of the 1861 dollar coins were struck under the authority of the Confederate States of America and they are unique among regular United States coins in that respect. The mint was officially closed by order of the Confederate Congress on June 1, 1861.

The Dahlonega mint building served as an assay office and repository for the Confederate Treasury during the Civil War. It was donated to the State of Georgia and became the main building for the North Georgia Agricultural College in 1873. Unfortunately a fire broke out in 1878 and the building burned to the ground. A new building was constructed on the foundation and it exists today as Price Memorial Hall of the North Georgia College and State University.

One-year Dahlonega type coins:

  • 1855 Type 2 gold dollar
  • 1839 Classic Head quarter eagle
  • 1854 Three dollar gold piece
  • 1838 Classic Head half eagle
  • 1839 Liberty Head half eagle, with obverse mint mark.

1857-D Half Eagle, graded PCGS XF-40.

The New Orleans Mint

The building for the New Orleans mint was a neo-classical structure designed by well-known architect William Strickland, who was paid $300 for a set of watercolor and ink drawings and 16 pages of manuscript specifications. Strickland unfortunately never visited New Orleans and his designs were better suited for firm ground such as was found in Philadelphia. The soft soil of New Orleans did not provide a suitable foundation for Strickland’s building design, which meant that many repairs, reconstructions, and makeshift accommodations were later required in order to keep the facility operational. By the early 1840’s the main building was deemed to be in immediate danger of collapse and architect James Gallier, Sr. was hired to effect repairs. He installed many steel tie rods and plates to shore up the weakened structure. Later repairs included installation of new support structures below the melting room and replacement of wooden beams and floor supports with iron beams.

The New Orleans mint was much larger than the Charlotte and Dahlonega facilities. It was a three-story brick structure with a granite basement, consisting of a central section and two wings. The overall length was 282 feet and the depth was about 180 feet. Construction was nearly completed by 1837 and coining equipment was installed. By the end of that year Presidents Jackson and Van Buren had appointed many mint personnel, including a Superintendent, treasurer, assayer, melter/refiner, and coiner. Coining operations began in 1838 with the production of silver dimes. Gold coinage began in 1839 with a small mintage of quarter eagle coins. Throughout its service, the New Orleans mint produced gold and silver coins only. All gold denominations from dollars through double eagles were made at New Orleans.

As was the case at the Charlotte and Dahlonega facilities, coining operations at New Orleans were interrupted by the Civil War. On January 26, 1861 Louisiana voted to secede from the Union. The Federal employees at the Mint were allowed to continue in their posts as employees of the state of Louisiana. The state ceded the mint authority to the Confederacy and coining operations continued until the bullion supply ran short in April 1861. The mint changed ownership again in 1862 when the United States Marines recaptured the city from the Confederacy. The mint was not used in any official capacity until 1876 when it re-opened as an Assay Office. New coining equipment was eventually installed and the mint began striking new gold and silver coins starting in 1879. Over the next 30 years it became increasingly difficult to justify mint operations since coinage output from Philadelphia and San Francisco (and, starting in 1906, Denver) was adequate to serve the needs of commerce. Coining operations ceased in 1909. An assay office continued to operate on the 3rd floor of the building until 1931. A Naval Recruiting station, a Veteran’s Bureau dispensary and a dental clinic also made use of the facility. The building served as a federal prison until 1943 and then became a Coast Guard Receiving Station. Jurisdiction over the site was transferred from the Federal Government to the State of Louisiana in the 1960’s and was placed under the authority of the Louisiana State Museum Board. The mint opened to the public in 1979 as part of the state museum complex.

One-year New Orleans type coins:

  • 1855 Type 2 gold dollar
  • 1839 Classic Head quarter eagle
  • 1854 Three dollar gold piece
  • 1909 Indian Head half eagle
  • 1879 Type 3 double eagle.

1844-O Half Eagle, graded PCGS AU-53.

CategoriesCoin Article

The 1885-CC Morgan Dollar

As far as national events go, 1885 was a quiet year. Some noteworthy events that happened were on February 18th, when the literary classic “The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn” by Mark Twain was first published. On February 21st President Chester A. Arthur dedicated the Washington Monument. On March 4th Grover Cleveland succeeded Chester A. Arthur as President of the United States. On July 23rd, President U. S. Grant lost his final battle, dying of cancer at age 63. 1885 was also the year that President Cleveland signed off on the first closure of the Carson City Mint. Some coins were produced prior to that closure however, including the 1885 Morgan Dollar.

The Carson City Morgan Dollar of 1885 is a rather unusual coin. First consider the fact of its mintage of only 228,000. Excluding the 1895 Philadelphia minted Morgan of which the 12,000 business strikes were melted down by the government and none are known to exist, the 1885-CC Morgan has the third lowest mintage of the entire Morgan dollar series. Only the 1893 San Francisco with a mintage of 100,000 and the 1894 Philadelphia with a mintage of 110,000 business strikes had lower totals.

In the GSA mail bid sales of 1972-1974, 148,285 uncirculated examples of the 1885-CC dollar were offered with the minimum bid of $60.00. All but 31,569 were sold at that time; the remaining coins were sold in 1980. The 148,285 uncirculated coins that were offered in those sales account for nearly two thirds of the total mintage, meaning that the majority of the survivors are in uncirculated condition. Circulated examples are therefore quite rare, making it a bit challenging for collectors who are interested in building a circulated set. It is estimated that there are fewer than 7,000 examples in grades below MS-60. The famous Redfield hoard is said to have as many as 1,000 1885-CC Morgan’s making it the sixth scarcest Redfield date.

The strikes are generally full although there are some that are weakly struck in the hair above the ear. It is found with exceptional eye appeal with both frosty and proof-like surfaces, but many examples can also be very “baggy” with lots of obvious contact marks. There are about four die varieties, with the so-called VAM-4 or “thick dash under 8” variety being the only one that commands any premium.

The price spread between circulated Very Fine and the lowest grade of uncirculated, MS-60, is not that wide. Very Fine examples retail at around $490 and MS-60 at about $620. So for that little bit of extra cash, collectors are more apt to spend their money on a MS-60 examples than the lower grades. However the lower-grade pieces are much harder to find.

Approximate retail prices for various grades as of January 2024 are as follows: Good-4: $600, Very Good-8: $625, Fine-12: $635, Very Fine-20: $660, Extremely Fine-40: $725, About Uncirculated-50: $740, and Mint State-60: $800. If you are looking for a place to invest a few hundred dollars, you might enjoy a nice example of the 1885-CC Morgan Dollar.

The example pictured below is graded MS-64 by NGC.